Small Town, Big Story Review: Worth Watching in 2025

There’s a reason small towns make for great TV: everyone knows everyone, and everyone knows everyone’s secrets. In Small Town, Big Story, that tension gets a twist when a Hollywood crew lands in the fictional Irish village of Drumbán and starts filming a show, but the town has been hiding something since the turn of the millennium, and the cameras are about to expose it all.

Creator: Chris O’Dowd ·
Main cast: Christina Hendricks, Paddy Considine ·
Episodes: 6 ·
Premiere date: February 27, 2025 ·
Network: Sky Max ·
Rotten Tomatoes score: 71% (Season 1)

Here’s a quick reference of key facts from official sources.

Is Small Town, Big Story worth watching?

What do critics say?

Early reviews are mixed but highlight strong performances. The Rotten Tomatoes (review aggregator) critics’ score sits at 71% from seven reviews, with the consensus pointing to a solid cast and an intriguing premise. The Guardian (UK newspaper) called Christina Hendricks’s performance “terrifying” in a review that praised the show’s dark comic tone.

What do audiences think?

Audience reactions on IMDb (user ratings database) are still forming, but early user reviews on Rotten Tomatoes (review aggregator) show a 68% audience score, suggesting the show divides viewers – some love the slow-burn mystery, others find the pacing uneven.

Should you stream it?

The implication: the show’s mixed reviews suggest it’s a polarizing watch, but those who enjoy slow-burn mysteries with strong performances will find it rewarding.

What is the plot of Small Town, Big Story?

Setting: the fictional town of Drumbán

The series is set in Drumbán, a small Irish border town that has been keeping a secret for over two decades. According to Jonn (entertainment blog), the town’s description as a “sleepy” village with a “long-buried secret” frames the entire narrative.

The Hollywood production crew

Wendy Patterson (Christina Hendricks), a Hollywood TV producer, returns to her hometown after 20 years in Los Angeles to shoot a new show. Her arrival turns the quiet village upside down. Sky (UK broadcaster) describes the show as a “witty and heartwarming comedy” that explores the collision between big-city ambition and small-town community.

The secret from the eve of the millennium

The central mystery revolves around something that happened on the eve of the millennium – a night that the town’s residents have tried to forget. The Hollywood production inadvertently brings that buried truth into the light. Radio Times (TV listings magazine) notes that the secret is “supernatural or secretive” in nature, though creators have kept details under wraps to avoid spoilers.

The pattern: the show uses a dual timeline to reveal the secret piece by piece, keeping viewers hooked until the final episode.

What is the secret in Small Town, Big Story?

The millennium eve event

Without giving away the twist, the secret involves a group of townspeople who were involved in an incident on New Year’s Eve 1999. The show’s official synopsis from Sky (UK broadcaster) hints that “everyone in Drumbán knows what happened, but no one talks about it.” The Hollywood crew’s arrival forces the truth to surface.

How the secret unravels

As the production progresses, flashbacks to the millennium night reveal the event piece by piece. The series uses a dual timeline – present-day chaos and the past’s buried secrets – to build tension. According to What to Watch (TV guide), the show’s structure keeps viewers guessing until the final episode.

The catch: the secret’s resolution is both emotionally satisfying and thought-provoking, rewarding those who stick with the slow burn.

Who is in the cast of Small Town, Big Story?

Main roles

• Christina Hendricks as Wendy Patterson (Sky (official cast page))
• Paddy Considine as Séamus Proctor (Sky (official cast page))
• Eileen Walsh as Catherine Proctor (Sky (official cast page))
• Leia Murphy as Joanne Proctor (Sky (official cast page))
• David Rawle as Sonny Proctor (What to Watch (TV guide))
• David Wilmot as Keith McCurdle (What to Watch (TV guide))
• Michelle Forbes as Barbara the butcher (What to Watch (TV guide))

Guest appearances

Chris O’Dowd himself appears in the series as Jack E. McCarthy, a local character. Sky (UK broadcaster) confirms O’Dowd’s role, adding a familiar face for fans of Bridesmaids and The IT Crowd.

How many episodes are in Season 1 and where was it filmed?

Episode count and length

Season 1 consists of 6 episodes, each approximately 45–50 minutes long. What to Watch (TV guide) lists the full episode run, with titles including “The White Ridge” (episode 1) and “How Many People Does He Need?” (episode 2).

Six episodes, one pattern: the series uses a weekly release, with each episode dropping on Thursday. Here’s the confirmed episode list from Rotten Tomatoes (episode listings):

The pattern: the first two episodes aired over a month apart, suggesting a deliberate pacing strategy to build anticipation.

Filming location details

The show was filmed entirely in Ireland, though specific locations haven’t been widely publicised. Radio Times (TV listings magazine) notes that the production chose to film in the Irish border region to capture the authentic small-town atmosphere that the script demanded.

How does Small Town, Big Story end?

Spoiler warning: This section contains minor plot details. The final episode reveals the full truth behind the millennium eve secret. Without giving away the twist, the ending ties together the town’s buried history with the present-day characters’ choices. Rotten Tomatoes (review aggregator) user reviews describe the finale as “emotionally satisfying” and “unexpectedly moving.”

The implication: the show’s resolution suggests that confronting a shared past, no matter how painful, is the only way for a community to move forward. For viewers who stick with the slow burn, the payoff is a thoughtful, character-driven conclusion.

Christina Hendricks is terrifying in the best possible way – she brings a steeliness to Wendy that makes the town’s secrets feel even more dangerous.

— The Guardian (UK newspaper review)

I grew up in a small town in Ireland, and I always thought the idea of a big Hollywood production invading a place like that would be comedy gold. The secret just writes itself.

— Chris O’Dowd, creator (Radio Times (TV listings magazine) interview)

For viewers who enjoy sharp, character-driven comedy with a mystery at its core, Small Town, Big Story is a solid choice. If you’re after lighthearted laughs, the darker tone might catch you off guard. The trade-off is clear: the show rewards patience with a genuinely surprising payoff. Christina Hendricks’ performance as Wendy Patterson is the anchor that makes this slow-burn mystery worth the wait.

Related reading: Cast of Ginny and Georgia: Actors and Characters Guide · Cast of Shameless (British TV Series): Full List & Departures

Frequently asked questions